Intermarkets' Privacy Policy
Support


Donate to Ace of Spades HQ!


Contact
Ace:
aceofspadeshq at gee mail.com
Buck:
buck.throckmorton at protonmail.com
CBD:
cbd at cutjibnewsletter.com
Doof:
doof2112 at proton.me
joe mannix:
mannix2024 at proton.me
MisHum:
petmorons at gee mail.com
J.J. Sefton:
sefton at cutjibnewsletter.com


Recent Entries
Absent Friends
Captain Whitebread 2026
Jon Ekdahl 2026
Jay Guevara 2025
Jim Sunk New Dawn 2025
Jewells45 2025
Bandersnatch 2024
GnuBreed 2024
Captain Hate 2023
moon_over_vermont 2023
westminsterdogshow 2023
Ann Wilson(Empire1) 2022
Dave In Texas 2022
Jesse in D.C. 2022
OregonMuse 2022
redc1c4 2021
Tami 2021
Chavez the Hugo 2020
Ibguy 2020
Rickl 2019
Joffen 2014
AoSHQ Writers Group
A site for members of the Horde to post their stories seeking beta readers, editing help, brainstorming, and story ideas. Also to share links to potential publishing outlets, writing help sites, and videos posting tips to get published. Contact OrangeEnt for info:
maildrop62 at proton dot me
Cutting The Cord And Email Security
Moron Meet-Ups





















« Ducks Redux | Main | Update On August 6, 2001, "A Day Of Infamy" »
August 09, 2005

The Space Shuttle Is a "Hoopty"

Which is this blogger's slang for a broken-down old junker.

The Space Shuttle never did all that much. I think it was originally sold not according to its usefulness -- it can't do much that a conventional rocket can't -- but on the basis of its putative gee-whiz factor, a real live spaceship, launching into the heavens and landing again. It was sold, I imagine, on the intangible benefits of exiciting a whole new generation about the wonders of exploration and science.

But even as a kid I was a little underwhelmed by the Shuttle. Partly that was out of childhood ignorance and unreasonable expectations; a real space ship, I thought, ought to be able to manage more than an orbital mission. Or a scientific mission (many of these scientific missions concocted by fourth-graders in unending public-relations maneuvers to justify continuing the program) to determine how spiders build their webs in zero-g.

Is this really a concern for anybody? I can't even imagine arachnologists being particularly excited about spiders in zero-g. See, they don't actually live in zero-g. So what the hell does that tell us? That creatures will behave slightly differently, and be a little disoriented, in an enviornment entirely alien to them? For this we need $500 million shuttle missions?

It's like designing an experiment to find out how a pack of pumas behave when addicted to smack and forced to live 24/7 in one of the seedy back-booths at the Viper Room.

Sorta fun, yes, and it would be just terrific to see Steven Dorff mauled by junkie hipster pumas, but is that really the sort of science that we're interested in funding?

Depends on the price, I guess. If it could be done for a ten thousand or so, it seems well worth it to me. More than that, and I'd demand a bigger name celebrity than Steven Dorff. Someone like, say, Stacey Q, or Rip Taylor. Or, preferably, both.

The newest or best two shuttles should be maintained for those few missions actually requiring the shuttles' capabilities. Ferrying people to the boondoggle-but-too-much-money-sunk-into-it-to-abandon-it-now international space station; fixing or recapturing malfunctioning satellites; maybe even the rare space rescue mission. But it doesn't seem worth the price or risk to continue sending the shuttles up on routine, make-work missions that do little but serve as PR for NASA funding (and not very well at that).

NASA should stick by and large to unmanned probes, launched by conventional rockets. If they want a real gee-whiz, inspire-a-generation-of-kids-(and adults) mission, they ought to go back to the Moon again. Yes, it's been done, but not in my lifetime (or at least not in the working-memory part of my lifetime), and I'm sure they can think of some new twist on the mission to make it seem new.

Like-- how would monkeys in space-suits react to the Moon's reduced gravity? Something fun like that. Toss a bushel of bananas into the low-gravity non-air and watch those monkeys go literally ape-shit berserk trying to catch them, jumping around and doing f'n' back-flips like acrobatic retards on Red Bull.

Not really science so much as the world's most expensive reality TV show.

And of course I'd watch.

Shuttles to be Retired by 2010: Which is a good idea, but until then, let's ixne on the frequent and frequently useless shuttle flights. Only launch them when actually, genuinely needed, and stop with all this idiocy about these ungainly, awkward flyin' minivans "exciting a generation of children about the wonders of science."

Thanks to My perpetual tormentor Dave From It's Old.



posted by Ace at 12:17 PM
Comments



"Like-- how would monkeys in space-suits react to the Moon's reduced gravity? "

You, my friend, deserve a Nobel Prize.

Posted by: ken on August 9, 2005 12:23 PM

Ace, just so you know, what you called for *is* the plan. In case you bothered to, you know, read about it.

I'm just sayin' ;-)

Cheers,
Dave at Garfield Ridge

Posted by: Dave at Garfield Ridge on August 9, 2005 12:36 PM

Ouch Dave... you gotta give him credit since he thought of the same thing NASA came up with. ACE can't help it if NASA pays their computer geeks millions to get their ideas out faster.

Posted by: El Capitan on August 9, 2005 12:40 PM

There doesn't seem to be any big lizard men up there for me to fight or green-skinned women to tear my shirt off for, so, really, what's the point?

You've seen one big empty void with the occasional ball of hot gas you've seen 'em all.

Posted by: Capt. James Tiberius Kirk on August 9, 2005 12:41 PM

Way to work in a Stacey Q reference. That can't be easy.

Posted by: Sean M. on August 9, 2005 12:48 PM

Yes, it's been done, but not in my lifetime (or at least not in the working-memory part of my lifetime), and I'm sure they can think of some new twist on the mission to make it seem new.

They can make it a reality show where astronauts get voted off the moon. That'll get the viewers watching.

BTW, the term "hoopty" to describe a broken-down vehicle has been around for years and years.

Posted by: Steve L. on August 9, 2005 12:51 PM

The original intent was for shuttle flights to be far more frequent than proved feasible. The whole program turned into a boutique operation once that plan failed.


So now you are right, but then it looked like it could be a real winner, and greatly lower the cost of lifting satellites into orbit and doing other things.


Live and learn.

Posted by: on August 9, 2005 12:54 PM

The whole space progrman's been an anticlimatic 'er, I guess that's kinda interesting or something' letdown since the 'man on the moon' moment. Nothing can ever again match that.

People still say 'If we can put a man on the moon, why can't we..."

No one ever or will say: 'If we can put a manned, reusable quasi plane looking thing in low space orbit, why can't we..."

I mean, who cares? I get it. We can go into space. We proved it. What else ya got? Frankly, nothing up there interests me anyway. Maybe, maybe if the Chinese plan on putting a man on Mars, we try to beat them (just out of spite) but even then, big deal.

Posted by: Ray Midge on August 9, 2005 12:56 PM

Where I'm from it's hoopy. (no t)

Posted by: right on August 9, 2005 12:58 PM

Ouch, Ace-- that's cold. Just trying to help.

Anyway, as you read for yourself, the Shuttle will be used for the missions it has to be used for, mainly, finishing up ISS. And then it's gone. Manned flight after that will be handled purely by partially reusable vehicles, namely the Crew Excursion Vehicle, which will be an unpowered capsule atop expendable rockets. And, the plan is to incorporate the CEV into the designs for the Moon vehicle (basically, as the front-end "control pod" for the larger, almost-certainly-to-be-built-in-orbit lunar hotrod).

Dynamite on paper, surely to be expensive and delayed.

Still, a long, sad way from the X-Wing they keep promising me.

Cheers,
Dave at Garfield Ridge

Posted by: Dave at Garfield Ridge on August 9, 2005 01:02 PM

Where I'm from we call them 'beaters'

Posted by: BrewFan on August 9, 2005 01:09 PM

it would be just terrific to see Steven Dorff mauled by junkie hipster pumas

Finally, someone has the balls to say what we've all been thinking. Bravo, sir. Bravo.

Only launch them when actually, genuinely needed

Example?

There's not one single aspect of the space program that is needed. If it were part of a focused plan to make bigger and better weapons, i could see the point, but the Air Force takes care of all that. NASA is one of the biggest wastes of taxpayer money in the federal budget.

Posted by: Phinn on August 9, 2005 01:30 PM

Even funnier than watching monkeys in spacesuits chasing bananas in zero-gee?

Watching monkeys in spacesuits and space helmets trying to eat a banana.

The experiment that I want to see is an explosion in space.

We've seen billions of movie special effects space explosions, but we have no idea what one really looks like.

Posted by: Rob@L&R on August 9, 2005 01:30 PM

So, they had to land Discovery in Cali, eh?

If they were smart, they'd douse the thing in gasoline, right there at the end of Runway 22 at Edwards, torch it, and collect the insurance money. Use the $1 million or so saved from not having to bring that heap back to Florida to study the feasibility of your intriguing monkey-moon idea.

Posted by: Rocketeer on August 9, 2005 01:34 PM

If NASA hadn't been pissing away all this money on the space shuttle, I'd have my damn flying car by now.

shakes fist

Posted by: Dave in Orbit on August 9, 2005 01:37 PM

Already done that, Rob.

Without atmosphere and gravity, explosions are spherical.

Cheers,
Dave at Garfield Ridge

P.S. Those "Trinity" videos are outstanding products, worth every penny. Oh, and they're narrated by William Shatner-- what a two-fer!

Posted by: Dave at Garfield Ridge on August 9, 2005 01:38 PM

The experiment that everyone REALLY wanted to see performed, in full color video, is all the positions in the Kama Sutra in zero-G.

Still no word (or video) on sex in space. That would perk up public interest, would it not?

In fact, the Shuttle was hobbled in the beginning by political compromise. I'd give the engineers behind it credit for making something, anything, out of it.

Posted by: Whitehall on August 9, 2005 01:46 PM

Here's more on the super pointless space shuttle: http://www.idlewords.com/2005/08/a_rocket_to_nowhere.htm

Posted by: NathanB on August 9, 2005 02:32 PM

Iraq critic arguments and Shuttle critic arguments always sounded similar to me in that they both base them on money, necessity, risk and return benefits.

The Iraq war never did all that much. I think it was originally sold not according to its usefulness -- it can't do much that a conventional embargo can't -- but on the basis of its putative gee-whiz factor, a real live war, launching rockets into the heavens and landing again. It was sold, I imagine, on the intangible benefits of a exiciting whole new government about the wonders of democracy and freedom.

Posted by: on August 9, 2005 03:08 PM

Look into the concept of "sunk costs". You do not judge a project's value based on how much capital has gone into it. Is the ISS of value? If yes, continue funding. If no, let it burn up over Papau New Guinea.

IMO, if the ISS is not working towards a construction platform for interplanetary spacecraft--either directly or indirectly through fundamental research--then it's not of value. People who jizz over "science" without a qualifier are not the people who should be making these decisions.

One argument for the SS that I have heard before is that it provides a visible face to the public in regards to the space program, which helps keep funding flowing. I see their point, but really, you know what catches folks eyes? The Martian rover; crashing into a comet; Voyager. All of these (unmanned) missions were cheap, interesting, had great visuals, and advance space exploration better than every SS mission where they drank Tang and juggled geese in zero-G.

Sending humans into space is only valuable if it leads to sending lots of humans into space. The SS ain't it.

Posted by: rho on August 9, 2005 03:10 PM

Look into the concept of "sunk costs". You do not judge a project's value based on how much capital has gone into it.

No, you judge it by the utility of what you get for your money, as compared to the utility of everything else that could possibly have been obtained with that money.

Space-socialism projects don't measure up no matter how you slice it.

One argument for the SS that I have heard before is that it provides a visible face to the public in regards to the space program, which helps keep funding flowing.

There's a term for that: propaganda.

Posted by: Phinn on August 9, 2005 03:30 PM

Hey Phinn, I bet I could get $50 bucks at a pawn shop for your computer and spend that feeding some homeless people.

When can I come pick up your stuff?

Posted by: on August 9, 2005 05:09 PM

Its real easy to criticize, alot harder to actually do something. The need for humans to be able to operate beyond Earth is going to be imperative, one of these days. What form that will take, we don't currently know. Maybe a mission to divert an asteroid, maybe a mining mission to collect Helium 3 from the Moon, maybe to form space colonies to escape from Islamic domination of the Earth, who knows? But you know what? The Space Shuttle does some amazing things, and I defy anyone to do it better. Sure, that may be possible, but rather than criticizing, try beating it.

The Space Shuttle just returned 13 tons of test results, replacement and broken parts, and trash from the Space Station. From Earth orbit to California, at very near to 70 degrees F, 50% relative humidity, 100% breathable environment, less than 2G force applied.
Think about that, and try to come up with a system which can do that other than the Space Shuttle.
Little teeny return capsules cannot.

Go ahead, lets see you do it, instead of whining about the Shuttle.

Put up or shut up!

Posted by: j.pickens on August 9, 2005 07:43 PM

Hey Phinn, I bet I could get $50 bucks at a pawn shop for your computer and spend that feeding some homeless people. When can I come pick up your stuff?

Hey, nameless fuckwad, was my computer bought with tax money? No? Then promptly fuck off.

Show me the part of the Constitution where it says that the federal government has the power to launch science experiments into space. I must have missed the "Space Exploration Clause" in ConLaw class.

Conservatives profess to be for limited government, for a strict reading of the Constitution, for a return to the doctrine of limited and enumerated powers. Why not here? Just because some people find space stuff to be cool, groovy and generally neat-o does NOT give the federal government the power to do it. Go play with your Star Trek dolls and get your fucking hand out of my wallet.

There is nothing about the space program that justifies forcilby extracting people's hard-earned money and spending it on space launches. It's ridiculous.

If it were economically sound, private enterprise would do it (and do it better). Because it's a complete boondoggle, the gov't is naturally the one to do it. No one can piss money away like the good old federal gov't.

My decision to buy my computer, in contrast, was economically sound. I made that decision with my own fucking money, even considering all the other things I could have done with that money.

It's called economic calculation. Look it up.

Posted by: Phinn on August 9, 2005 11:17 PM

Go ahead, lets see you do it, instead of whining about the Shuttle. Put up or shut up!

J. Pickens, I have a better challenge for you: you go out and convince people to VOLUNTARILY support a space program.

Solicit donations. Put a call out for investors. Tell them all about the asteroids, the helium, the colonies. Show them your sci fi movies if you like, just to get them in the mood.

See how much money you collect. When you get more than $27, give me a call and we'll talk.

The truth is that the space program is not economically sound. This is the acid test. We have another term for things that are not economically sound: "waste of money."

Or, you can just tax people and spend it for them.

Next time you bitch about welfare or a bloated and inefficient military budget, or the cost of various economic regulations left over from FDR's New Deal, think about how you chose to piss away billions of dollars on wasteful government programs.

Posted by: Phinn on August 9, 2005 11:23 PM

See, private enterprise is the way to go.

The federal gov't couldn't make a pot of coffee for $100 million.

Posted by: Phinn on August 9, 2005 11:26 PM

The Space Shuttle just returned 13 tons of test results, replacement and broken parts, and trash from the Space Station.

Great. A multi-billion dollar garbage truck.


I still want my freaking flying car!

Posted by: Dave in Texas on August 10, 2005 09:38 AM

You want to know why the SS sucks royal @$$?

The Columbia was a prototype. When it was launched everyone was told that it was a prototype. By the time it landed from its first mission, The American Memorial to The Soviet System (aka NASA) had already decided to make 10 IDENTICAL COPIES!! (only 7?8? were built) In other words, 20 years later we STILL don't have a "Production Model" space shuttle.

We would have been better off if NASA hadn't managed to kill off the Air Force's competing "DynaSoar" or X-20 program.

As it is, I'm betting on Mr. Rutan and the Brit.

Posted by: EbeneezerSquid on August 10, 2005 06:19 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?








Now Available!
The Deplorable Gourmet
A Horde-sourced Cookbook
[All profits go to charity]
Top Headlines
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: Jensen Huang dips his wick in the wrong place; Tech outages? Coincidence or enemy action? Democrat voting scam in Alaska, and the feckless Republican Party does nothing; the long game in Iran, and more!
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: Was the U.S. election stolen? Spain is next on the riot parade, Israel's political structure is a problem, Trump, Iran, Rubio and Vance...and more!
The low-ranking drudge who lied and claimed he was a major Trump advisor, and wrote a book ignorantly attacking Trump as "Anonymous" (so that no one would know he was a nobody with no insider knowledge about the President's decisions), takes a self-righteous stance against marital affairs:
Miles Taylor
@MilesTaylorUSA

So will Trump give back the $25M Nvidia put into his ballroom while its CEO was dating a Chinese spy?

but...
Katie Miller
@KatieMiller

Miles Taylor cheated on his wife with the Secretary's Executive Assistant while he was Deputy Chief of Staff of the Department of Homeland Security.

Taylor denies the accusation. I guess we'll see.
Dear hot Chinese and/or Russian spies.

While my job title doesn't indicate it I work all day on cutting edge AI models and advanced chip architecture.

And I just can't stop talking about all the awesome things I am working on.

So totally don't come by my neighborhood bar at 6 PM tomorrow and starting chatting with me. I mean get a few drinks in me and who knows what secrets I might spill.

Posted by: 18-1 at November 12, 2026

PS, me too. I've got more chips than Frito-Lay.
Seinfeld did it first

How to know if the suspiciously hot woman who inexplicably wants to have sex in your office at Open AI is a spy

the Bee: How to know if your girlfriend is a Chinese Spy
thanks to Biden's dog sniffs a lot of malarkey and Kindltot and runner
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: A quick postmortem of the savage beating suffered by the Republican Party and Donald Trump. And a new reason to hit the tip jar...Buy Guns For Sefton!
Email confirmed as once used by the Muskily Heterosexual James Talarico found in leak of emails of Fling.com sex dating site:
An email address that James Talarico's attorneys confirmed belonged to and was at one time used by the Texas Democratic U.S. Senate candidate appears in a database search result associated with the adult dating website Fling.com's 2011 data breach. A Fling.com account was created with Talarico's email address just before Talarico began teaching sixth graders.

The result lists the username "mohawk787" and an account creation timestamp of December 26, 2010, at 20:56:49. The profile's interests field lists "FETISH," "GROUPSEX," "SEXUAL RELATIONS," "ONLINE FLIRTING," and "OTHER."

Townhall shared the information described in this article with the Talarico campaign and requested comment Friday morning, and in response, a mere 35 minutes later, received a four-page, detailed letter from legal counsel for Talarico that addressed some, but not all of the information described in this report.

"Well I can't believe the trans-child-obsessed Confirmed Bachelor James Talarico is into group fetish shit," said noted void phantom Doctor Nullity, The Man Who Never Existed
I'm not the guy who noted this, I saw it on X (Razib Khan maybe), but The Bulwark could be "audience capture". It might have started as the Frum / 90s-Kristol / NRO classic Eisenhower Republicanism. But nobody was reading the Bulwark except leftists.

Tallyrand has a quote on this, "I am their leader so I must follow them".

Same goes for David French, Christianity Today, and the "Anxious Bench" side of Patheos. They may have started out Christian. But it wasn't Christians signing their checks.

Posted by: 88C+u at
Flashback: "trans man" Lawyer freaks out after a judge denies "his" motion. He's ultimately arrested. "He" makes so much drama he was just recruited to develop a new CW show.
I'm just wondering if this flighty high-calorie pyrsyn is also in the news today for other reasons....
Update: No, it's not. Zee/Zem says they's name is like "Rob Hopkins" or something.
Story here, courtesy of The Blade
Buck Throckmorton on The Continuing Crisis (American Spectator) podcast discusses prediction markets.
[CBD]
Forgotten 80s Mystery Click
[Song title]
Don't breathe down my neck, no
I got no trophies on display
I sign them away
I mean what the heck
All of your promises
Don't fill me with pride no
I just wanna get out on the floor
And do the Cuban slide, slide, slide, slide
Recent Comments
naturalfake: " [i]Turkey in Poblano Mole by Rick Bayless - ..."

Quarter Twenty : "There is no section of the grocery store more comp ..."

meh: "ProTip: Many Walmarts have a man door with man che ..."

Community Notes: "[i]And so they move things around and force you to ..."

fd: "Canon made the first commercial PC laser printer. ..."

Krebs v Carnot: Epic Battle of the Cycling Stars (TM): " Of late I have noticed that grocery stores are e ..."

fd: "Canon makes good inkjets, as they are. Most are bu ..."

[/i][/b][/s]Biden's Dog sniffs a whole lotta malarkey,: "Turkey in Poblano Mole by Rick Bayless - I pre ..."

Marcus T: "“I have told you these things, so that in me ..."

[/i][/b][/s]Biden's Dog sniffs a whole lotta malarkey,: "BD, Brother or Epson. If you use it a lot, get one ..."

naturalfake: " Too bad Tesla hasn't come up with a spiffy SUV R ..."

tankdemon: "I prefer the winks before the nudges. ..."

Bloggers in Arms
Some Humorous Asides
Archives