Intermarkets' Privacy Policy
Support


Donate to Ace of Spades HQ!


Contact
Ace:
aceofspadeshq at gee mail.com
Buck:
buck.throckmorton at protonmail.com
CBD:
cbd at cutjibnewsletter.com
Doof:
doof2112 at proton.me
joe mannix:
mannix2024 at proton.me
MisHum:
petmorons at gee mail.com
J.J. Sefton:
sefton at cutjibnewsletter.com


Recent Entries
Absent Friends
Captain Whitebread 2026
Jon Ekdahl 2026
Jay Guevara 2025
Jim Sunk New Dawn 2025
Jewells45 2025
Bandersnatch 2024
GnuBreed 2024
Captain Hate 2023
moon_over_vermont 2023
westminsterdogshow 2023
Ann Wilson(Empire1) 2022
Dave In Texas 2022
Jesse in D.C. 2022
OregonMuse 2022
redc1c4 2021
Tami 2021
Chavez the Hugo 2020
Ibguy 2020
Rickl 2019
Joffen 2014
AoSHQ Writers Group
A site for members of the Horde to post their stories seeking beta readers, editing help, brainstorming, and story ideas. Also to share links to potential publishing outlets, writing help sites, and videos posting tips to get published. Contact OrangeEnt for info:
maildrop62 at proton dot me
Cutting The Cord And Email Security
Moron Meet-Ups





















« It's A Fact | Main | Murtha Called For Iraq Exit In a Snit? »
December 11, 2005

Defeatist Democrats, Always "Taken Out of Context"

Howard Dean is claiming his statement about the war in Iraq being unwinnable was "taken out of context."

Brit Hume offered the full context on Thursday. It doesn't seem to help him much:

"I supported President Bush, the first President Bush's war in Iraq. I supported this president Bush's war in Afghanistan. But I do not believe in making the same mistake twice. And America appears to have made the same mistake twice. I wish the president had paid more attention to the history of Iraq before we'd gotten in there. The idea that we're going to win this war is an idea that is unfortunately just plain wrong, and I've seen this before in my life. It cost us 25,000 brave American soldiers in Vietnam, and I don't want to go down that road again."

Nothing there that suggests a different plan would make it winnable, or that caveats his claim that it's not winnable. In fact, he compares it to the most famously unwinnable war in American history, Vietnam. (At least it's so in the conventional liberal wisdom.)

And of course John Murtha is claiming he wasn't accurately quoted, either, regarding his now-radioactive call for "immediate" withdrawal of troops from Iraq. Brit Hume's having none of that, either:

Even before today, Democrats were complaining that Rep. John Murtha's plan to remove troops from Iraq has been "mischaracterized" for political reasons, saying the Pennsylvania Democrat never proposed an immediate withdrawal. In fact, in announcing his plan last month, Murtha said his plan would "immediately redeploy U.S. troops," adding, "It is time to bring them home." He said some troops should be rebased in the region with a Marine force over the horizon. A few days later, he made clear that by that, he meant outside Iraq.

Liberal partisan Democrat Juan Williams is also fond of this silliness. He'll spend ten minutes attacking Bush for being so "inflexible" about withdrawal, supporting the Democrats' calls for such, and then when it's pointed out that the Democrats are supporting, effectively, surrender and defeat, he'll claim that the Democrats aren't really suggesting anything at all different than Bush, and so it's unfair to attack them.

He claims that since Bush says he wants security followed by a withdrawal, and the Democrats want a withdrawal which they hope will lead to security, both positions are in fact essentially the same and it's cheap and demagogic to suggest the Democrats want anything different than Bush.

Of course this is absurd. Bush demands objective goals be met, and then he hopes for a fairly quick withdrawal. While the Democrats demand a fairly quick withdrawal, and hope that objective military goals will be achieved by the Iraqis. That's a pretty big difference in prioritization there, and not even Juan Williams could be so stupid as to not comprehend it.

Well, wait: This is Juan Williams we're talking about. So perhaps I shouldn't suggest he's being dishonest in his partisan hackery. Maybe he really is that stupid. Certainly I don't foresee him unifying the four forces anytime soon.

But Juan makes no sense any way you slice it. If it's true the Democrats aren't suggesting anything different than Bush, why are they all pounding on him? How can you criticize a man when you're also claiming you support the same policies he does?

Juan Williams and other liberal partisans believe in drawing distinctions for their own political advantage, but when their opponents point out those distinctions, they claim there aren't really any meaningful distinctions in the first place.

It's a replay of the Democrats' notorious 2004 campaign "position" on gay marriage: John Kerry has the exact same policy on gay marriage as Bush and Cheney, but Bush and Cheney are terrible homophobes for supporting that policy.

At the risk of being obvious (but apparently some liberals need to read the obvious): You can claim to either have a better policy than Bush, or you can claim your policy is exactly the same as Bush's, but you can't claim your policy is both exactly the same as Bush's and also, somehow, better than Bush's. Either they're different or they're not.

The real "context" which explains this nonsense is that Democrats want it both ways. They want to be viewed as tough and resolute on matters military while simultaneously rejecting military solutions and calling for withdrawals; they want to placate their strenuously antiwar base while reassuring moderates who think that maybe it's a good idea to win wars our country begins.

These competing demands really can't be met simultaneously, so they say one thing one day and the complete opposite another, and then cry foul when someone (accurately) quotes one day's statement.

The real "context," in other words, is that they don't have a policy at all on the War on Terror. At least none they feel comfortable publicly and clearly admitting to.


posted by Ace at 03:13 AM
Comments



Personally, I think the Democrats are employing the 'broken clock' principle, in that it is right twice a day.

If they continue to hark on about bringing the troops home, then when they do start to come home, as they are expected to start reducing numbers in the near future, then they can claim credit for 'ending the war'.

Posted by: Ring on December 11, 2005 03:25 AM

Yes, I've noted that myself. When troops are withdrawn -- as was always the plan, after Iraqi forces were able to hold the country themselves -- they want to say, "See? Withdrawing the troops was our idea all along!"

Well, yeahhhh... withdrawing in defeat was your idea all along.

But not withdrawing after a victory. That's definitely not an idea they support.

Posted by: ace on December 11, 2005 03:29 AM

Ace, your blog is totally boogered. Bold tags everywhere!

Posted by: someone on December 11, 2005 03:57 AM

Kerry and Bush may have had the same opinion on gay marriage, but who got the almighty Simperin Sully's support?

If only Bush had that, it woulda been a mandate.

(No pun intended)

Posted by: MH on December 11, 2005 04:17 AM

It's really beyond me how Democrats can tolerate so much incoherence and contradiction in the messages and positions. I mean, I understand WHY they're forced to be like this (being honest and open about what they believe and want would sink them in most statewide and all national elections) but it has to be frustrating for Democrats to constantly feel like they have to "fool" the public and back off whenever they tip their hand too far.

Maybe that explains the tone of liberal blogs, like that NY Times story about the differences between conservative and liberal blogs; it's the only place they can vent and say what they really think without worrying about whether what they say will hurt them or not.

Posted by: Moonbat_One on December 11, 2005 04:44 AM

Dean: "It cost us 25,000 brave American soldiers in Vietnam"

It has been pointed out that the number of American soldiers lost in Vietnam was 58,000. But perhaps Howard did not misspeak. He may think that 25,000 brave American soldiers were lost, and the other 33,000 were not brave.

Posted by: Bob M on December 11, 2005 07:46 AM

they want to placate their strenuously antiwar base while reassuring moderates who think that maybe it's a good idea to win wars our country begins.

This is the chink in the armor I've been yapping about since Dean took the Chairmanship of the DNC.

We can splinter the Democratic Party. I know we can.
But we have to do more than just give them the rope for which to hang themselves. Our congressman must continually force the Dems into either/or positions. In other words, it's time to call them out.


Posted by: Bart on December 11, 2005 07:51 AM

Bob M,

I noticed that mistake as well.

Maybe marines don't count as soldiers.

Posted by: Aaron on December 11, 2005 07:54 AM

Ace,

Saying that Kerry and Bush have the same position on gay "marriage" is like saying they have the same Iraq policy because they both put their names to the Use of Force Resolution.

Yes, Kerry says he's opposed to it. But what he's really opposed to is taking the heat from voters. He wants judges to impose it on us so he can wring his hands and claim there is nothing he can do. It is political cowardice. Whereas Bush stood up and took the heat for a FMA.

Your larger point still stands, however. On the strategic level, the only real debate amongst Democrats is this: "Is it 'America is bad but Bush is worse' or 'Bush is bad but America is worse'?"

On the tactical level, the only qustion is "How can we best implement our true policies without being horse-whipped and run out of town on a rail by the voters?"--in short, "How can we fool them today?". This accounts for the cognitive dissonance & political schizophrenia you note.

Posted by: Noel on December 11, 2005 08:19 AM

"I say it is time for a positive polarization. It is time to rip away the rhetoric and to divide on authentic lines."~Spiro Agnew

While I was looking for the casualty totals for Viet Nam under Nixon's presidency, I came across a great piece by Nixon's SecDef, Melvin Laird.
Link

And this Link will show why Bush needs to make a "Silent Majority" speech to the American people. Plus, it has graphs comparing the casaulty rate under Nixon and Johnson.

(Why Dean used the figure of 25,000 is puzzling. Surely he knows that is not the total number.)

Posted by: Bart on December 11, 2005 08:25 AM

Dean is trying to pull an Arafat, saying one thing to his supporters and another to the general public. But he keeps forgetting to speak Arabic when addressing the former.

Posted by: E Rey on December 11, 2005 10:15 AM

"Context"

They keep using that word. I do not think it means what they think it means.

Posted by: anon on December 11, 2005 12:02 PM

I love seeing Juan Williams cry. What would happen if Juan Williams was the conductor for Paul Anka's band?

Posted by: SWLiP on December 11, 2005 12:33 PM

At least the four legged donkey has a backbone unlike the two leeged kind

Posted by: spurwing plover on December 11, 2005 02:56 PM

It's really beyond me how Democrats can tolerate so much incoherence and contradiction in the messages and positions.

Democrats have become modern day sophists - taking positions that are only coherent or reasonable when taken without any context. They are, in other words, arguing for the sake of winning the argument.

What it comes down to is that there are no real historical or greater principles to which they move towards, except perhaps the applause that comes with a kiss-ass populism. But by that definition, they are subject to the worst sensibilities of an often angry and usually incoherent base.

Of course, that doesn't mean that Democrats don't adhere to any principles at all. It's just that, at least in toto, their principles are nihilistic: reject authority, reject structure, reject any conformity in which the conformity is life-affirming. It's post-modernism applied to politics - nothing has value in and of itself, and what value there is must be construed only after dissembling.

There are two problems that come from this. The first is that political parties, nations, and alliances are only valuable because all parties have, more or less, foregone their dissembled value in favor of the groups'. That's not collectivism, that's realpolitik. So by definition, Democrats cannot either see or add to the value that comes from an alliance, etc. The American strategy in Iraq at least seems unilateral, because, well, no single group would really benefit on the top line except the white-male American government. For shame, except that shame is really not condoned.

The larger problem is that achievable goals, real goals, that do not jibe with a crass materialistic analysis are simply beyond a Democrat world view. Freedom and liberty are abstracts that are only meaningful in the aggregate. If your lenses refuse to see value in the aggregate, then freedom and liberty remain words.

It's beyond understanding that Bush, or Christianity, The Patriot Act, or America could actually create an environment that respects and empowers individuals, because they are aggregate authoritarian structures. How, goes their line of reasoning, can a power structure abjure from exercising power? A simply materialistic analysis misses the abstracts, misses the bottom line. To the Democrats, it's all about the cost.

And so there are a lot of incoherent positions taken by Democrats. How do you feed a base which rejects the power structure in which you are attempting to operate. At some point, subversion begins to feed on its own tail.

Oscar Wilde said that the definition of a cynic is someone who knows the price of everything and the value of nothing. Our problem is that one of our two political parties has painted itself into a cynical corner, and the paints going to take a long, long time to dry.

Posted by: DeeDaGo on December 11, 2005 02:58 PM

"Democrats have become modern day sophists - taking positions that are only coherent or reasonable when taken without any context. They are, in other words, arguing for the sake of winning the argument."

Thank you for that comparison, it is so correct. I'm definitely going to have to use it in the future.

Posted by: Cutler on December 11, 2005 04:56 PM

The flaw in Melvin Laird's thesis (that I linked to earlier in this thread) is obvious. Laird believes the Iraqis can do what the South Vietnamese did: defend themselves with the increasing monitary and diplomatic support of the US while the US decreases the troop level. The flaw is that the lines were clearly delineated - North and South -- in Vietnam, whereas Iraq is infested with insurgents wearing no uniform.

Anyway, it's a good piece from an old codger who wants to reamin relevant in the political scene.

Posted by: Timmy in the Well on December 11, 2005 09:52 PM

I wish the president had paid more attention to the history of Iraq before we'd gotten in there.

Yes, it is SUCH a shame they don't study military history at West Point (what do they teach there anyway?), but fortunately our universities across the country are brimming with experts on such crucially relevant topics as History of Mesopotamian Sexual Awareness, History of Inuit Basketweaving and Pre-Roman Pagan Studies to guide us through these difficult times - if only we are wise enough to LISTEN to them.

Posted by: Scott on December 13, 2005 09:29 AM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?








Now Available!
The Deplorable Gourmet
A Horde-sourced Cookbook
[All profits go to charity]
Top Headlines
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: Jensen Huang dips his wick in the wrong place; Tech outages? Coincidence or enemy action? Democrat voting scam in Alaska, and the feckless Republican Party does nothing; the long game in Iran, and more!
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: Was the U.S. election stolen? Spain is next on the riot parade, Israel's political structure is a problem, Trump, Iran, Rubio and Vance...and more!
The low-ranking drudge who lied and claimed he was a major Trump advisor, and wrote a book ignorantly attacking Trump as "Anonymous" (so that no one would know he was a nobody with no insider knowledge about the President's decisions), takes a self-righteous stance against marital affairs:
Miles Taylor
@MilesTaylorUSA

So will Trump give back the $25M Nvidia put into his ballroom while its CEO was dating a Chinese spy?

but...
Katie Miller
@KatieMiller

Miles Taylor cheated on his wife with the Secretary's Executive Assistant while he was Deputy Chief of Staff of the Department of Homeland Security.

Taylor denies the accusation. I guess we'll see.
Dear hot Chinese and/or Russian spies.

While my job title doesn't indicate it I work all day on cutting edge AI models and advanced chip architecture.

And I just can't stop talking about all the awesome things I am working on.

So totally don't come by my neighborhood bar at 6 PM tomorrow and starting chatting with me. I mean get a few drinks in me and who knows what secrets I might spill.

Posted by: 18-1 at November 12, 2026

PS, me too. I've got more chips than Frito-Lay.
Seinfeld did it first

How to know if the suspiciously hot woman who inexplicably wants to have sex in your office at Open AI is a spy

the Bee: How to know if your girlfriend is a Chinese Spy
thanks to Biden's dog sniffs a lot of malarkey and Kindltot and runner
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: A quick postmortem of the savage beating suffered by the Republican Party and Donald Trump. And a new reason to hit the tip jar...Buy Guns For Sefton!
Email confirmed as once used by the Muskily Heterosexual James Talarico found in leak of emails of Fling.com sex dating site:
An email address that James Talarico's attorneys confirmed belonged to and was at one time used by the Texas Democratic U.S. Senate candidate appears in a database search result associated with the adult dating website Fling.com's 2011 data breach. A Fling.com account was created with Talarico's email address just before Talarico began teaching sixth graders.

The result lists the username "mohawk787" and an account creation timestamp of December 26, 2010, at 20:56:49. The profile's interests field lists "FETISH," "GROUPSEX," "SEXUAL RELATIONS," "ONLINE FLIRTING," and "OTHER."

Townhall shared the information described in this article with the Talarico campaign and requested comment Friday morning, and in response, a mere 35 minutes later, received a four-page, detailed letter from legal counsel for Talarico that addressed some, but not all of the information described in this report.

"Well I can't believe the trans-child-obsessed Confirmed Bachelor James Talarico is into group fetish shit," said noted void phantom Doctor Nullity, The Man Who Never Existed
I'm not the guy who noted this, I saw it on X (Razib Khan maybe), but The Bulwark could be "audience capture". It might have started as the Frum / 90s-Kristol / NRO classic Eisenhower Republicanism. But nobody was reading the Bulwark except leftists.

Tallyrand has a quote on this, "I am their leader so I must follow them".

Same goes for David French, Christianity Today, and the "Anxious Bench" side of Patheos. They may have started out Christian. But it wasn't Christians signing their checks.

Posted by: 88C+u at
Flashback: "trans man" Lawyer freaks out after a judge denies "his" motion. He's ultimately arrested. "He" makes so much drama he was just recruited to develop a new CW show.
I'm just wondering if this flighty high-calorie pyrsyn is also in the news today for other reasons....
Update: No, it's not. Zee/Zem says they's name is like "Rob Hopkins" or something.
Story here, courtesy of The Blade
Buck Throckmorton on The Continuing Crisis (American Spectator) podcast discusses prediction markets.
[CBD]
Forgotten 80s Mystery Click
[Song title]
Don't breathe down my neck, no
I got no trophies on display
I sign them away
I mean what the heck
All of your promises
Don't fill me with pride no
I just wanna get out on the floor
And do the Cuban slide, slide, slide, slide
Recent Comments
Alberta Oil Peon: "It looks like a strange eye movement caused by the ..."

rhomboid: "It's just one of several, but the astonishing imag ..."

[/i][/b][/s]Biden's Dog sniffs a whole lotta malarkey,: "Hooray for Bollywood! https://tinyurl.com/53x9r ..."

Braenyard - some Absent Friends are more equal than others _ : "98 Cultural enlightenment. Afghan suspects accoun ..."

Helena Handbasket: ">>> 125 I find my self wondering how they dealt wi ..."

CharlieBrown'sDildo: "I find my self wondering how they dealt with Fiona ..."

[/i][/b][/s]Biden's Dog sniffs a whole lotta malarkey,: "Is it physically possible to roll one's eye that w ..."

Anonosaurus Wrecks, Now Is the Winter of Our Discontent[/s] [/i] [/u] [/b]: "Deranged Libs Fear Christian Nationalism More Than ..."

Skip: "Not that I do it, but seems spray on epoxy paint c ..."

Gayla Peavey: "While it is a rather macabre question, I find my s ..."

18-1: "I looked at a few other angles of that Bombdaddy v ..."

mindful webworker - this is a comment: "[i]800 yard sniper shots killing prominent politic ..."

Bloggers in Arms
Some Humorous Asides
Archives