Intermarkets' Privacy Policy
Support


Donate to Ace of Spades HQ!


Contact
Ace:
aceofspadeshq at gee mail.com
Buck:
buck.throckmorton at protonmail.com
CBD:
cbd at cutjibnewsletter.com
Doof:
doof2112 at proton.me
joe mannix:
mannix2024 at proton.me
MisHum:
petmorons at gee mail.com
J.J. Sefton:
sefton at cutjibnewsletter.com


Recent Entries
Absent Friends
Captain Whitebread 2026
Jon Ekdahl 2026
Jay Guevara 2025
Jim Sunk New Dawn 2025
Jewells45 2025
Bandersnatch 2024
GnuBreed 2024
Captain Hate 2023
moon_over_vermont 2023
westminsterdogshow 2023
Ann Wilson(Empire1) 2022
Dave In Texas 2022
Jesse in D.C. 2022
OregonMuse 2022
redc1c4 2021
Tami 2021
Chavez the Hugo 2020
Ibguy 2020
Rickl 2019
Joffen 2014
AoSHQ Writers Group
A site for members of the Horde to post their stories seeking beta readers, editing help, brainstorming, and story ideas. Also to share links to potential publishing outlets, writing help sites, and videos posting tips to get published. Contact OrangeEnt for info:
maildrop62 at proton dot me
Cutting The Cord And Email Security
Moron Meet-Ups





















« Gonzo Rightwing Comic Book Features Cybernetic Superhero Sean Hannity | Main | Swedish Man Reads Pornographic Stories To Six-Year-Olds As Part Of "Theater Project On Children's Sexuality" »
December 01, 2005

Hawaiian Supreme Court: Unborn Babies Are "Not Human Beings"

Apparently they're duck-billed platypusses, or maybe Gila monsters, or perhaps Jesus Lizards.

The statement was made in case deciding that a woman who killed her child by taking lots of drugs (including a hit of meth on the day of her delivery) couldn't be charged with manslaughter.

After all, all she did was kill a marmoset. Or maybe a three-toed sloth. Or a fruit bat. Or a ginko tree.

I'm not sure which, but it wasn't a human being. Judges told me so.

I suppose the decision has a certain amount of logic to it: If you can deliberately abort a child, why should it be a crime to negligently abort one?

The strange things one must be required to believe in order to fully support abortion on demand, no questions asked, just seem to continue growing in number.

Excellent Point By SobekPundit:

Interestingly, this descision does not rest on the "reasonsing" (such as it is) behind Roe v. Wade, which expressly recognized that a state has a legitimate interest in protecting the unborn. Roe decided that the woman's interest in individual autonomy trumps the state's interest (and, presumably, the fetus' interest in not having its arms torn out of their sockets).

But what interest is the Hawai'i Supreme Court trying to protect? It's not the mother's reproductive autonomy; the mother's interest in getting loaded? Since when is that a Constitutionally protected interest?

In fairness, crystal meth -- or, as I call it, "rock sugar" -- is really, really good.

I'm sure that somewhere in the Constitution there's a "penumbra" guaranteeing my right to get really cranked up on meth and then light sleeping hobos on fire.

But...

Hubris actually bothers to read the case, and finds it turns on statutory construction:

I skimmed over the actual decision. The court was applying Hawaii's statutory definition of "person":
HRS § 707-702(1)(a) states that "[a] person commits the offense of manslaughter if . . . [h]e recklessly causes the death of another person." HRS § 707-702(1)(a). The HPC generally defines "person" as "any natural person." HRS § 701-118(7) (1993). Furthermore, for the purposes of HRS chapter 707, HRS § 707-700 defines "person" as "a human being who has been born and is alive." HRS § 707-700.

If the statutes say (for the purposes of manslaughter) that a "person" is "a human being who has been born and is alive," how could the court find otherwise on that aspect of the case? There's no way the definition can be met until birth. Am I missing something?

Well... you're right that this seems to be the fault of the legislators, rather than the judges.

To a degree.

But bear in mind: the baby actually was born. The article states that she caused the death of her "newborn son."

Which gets back to the courts' job in interpreting the law. The damage was inflicted when the baby was, according to the statute, "not a human being," but the actual death was caused to (again according to the statute) "human being."

So, it wasn't a human being when she was killing it, but it was one when it was killed.

She did cause the death of a human being, it seems, because it was (as I read it) born alive, but in a deathly condition.


posted by Ace at 02:31 PM
Comments



You know, just because the unborn has a beating heart, moves on it's own, and sucks it thumb, doesn't mean it is alive. It is that short trip down the birth canal that count.

Posted by: carin on December 1, 2005 02:38 PM

Its not even the birth canal thing, it is 'Mothers Choice'. If she decides its a human, it is one. If she decides it is a cancerous growth, it is one. Notice that when someone injures a mother thus causing the death of the unborn, it can be murder. But if the mother does it, it is like trimming toenails.

Posted by: PHenry on December 1, 2005 02:43 PM

Exactly carin! There are brain waves and a heartbeat but that doesn't mean it's alive for heaven sakes! It's that "magic" when the "thing" meets air that transforms it to being human.

This is scientific ya know.

Posted by: Rightwingsparkle on December 1, 2005 02:44 PM

...and the Left ridicules religious people for believing in the doctrine of Transubstantiation. Sheesh.

The "fetus" somehow attains a magical property of personhood only upon exiting the birth canal? And what if some lowlife kills both mother and child? If I recall correctly, in most states the lowlife is charged with two counts of murder and not just one. How can the lawmakers reconcile this?

Posted by: Monty on December 1, 2005 02:56 PM

Interestingly, this descision does not rest on the "reasonsing" (such as it is) behind Roe v. Wade, which expressly recognized that a state has a legitimate interest in protecting the unborn. Roe decided that the woman's interest in individual autonomy trumps the state's interest (and, presumably, the fetus' interest in not having its arms torn out of their sockets).

But what interest is the Hawai'i Supreme Court trying to protect? It's not the mother's reproductive autonomy; the mother's interest in getting loaded? Since when is that a Constitutionally protected interest?

But I haven't read the case. If everything turns on statutory interpretation, then the "abortion rights" argument really falls flat. Even murder of a fully-grown human being is not criminal if there is no statute penalizing it.

Posted by: Sobek on December 1, 2005 03:00 PM

I skimmed over the actual decision. The court was applying Hawaii's statutory definition of "person":

HRS § 707-702(1)(a) states that "[a] person commits the offense of manslaughter if . . . [h]e recklessly causes the death of another person." HRS § 707-702(1)(a). The HPC generally defines "person" as "any natural person." HRS § 701-118(7) (1993). Furthermore, for the purposes of HRS chapter 707, HRS § 707-700 defines "person" as "a human being who has been born and is alive." HRS § 707-700.

If the statutes say (for the purposes of manslaughter) that a "person" is "a human being who has been born and is alive," how could the court find otherwise on that aspect of the case? There's no way the definition can be met until birth. Am I missing something?

Posted by: Hubris on December 1, 2005 03:03 PM

When do they start throwing the virgins (if they can find any) into Kileauea again?

Posted by: Jeff on December 1, 2005 03:08 PM
Posted by: Slublog on December 1, 2005 03:18 PM

Hubris said, "There's no way the definition can be met until birth."

True, but the story says the boy actually was born alive. The only question, then, is whether acts done to something that is not yet a "person" suffice when the non-person thing becomes a person.

And you're right about the statute. It looks like the court wasn't being unreasonable here. If the legislature had defined the word "person" as including gila monsters and ginko trees, the Supreme Court would have to follow that definition.

Posted by: Sobek on December 1, 2005 03:23 PM

Congratulations, Slublog!

Posted by: Sobek on December 1, 2005 03:24 PM

It is that short trip down the birth canal that count.

The sad part is that it has to be a complete trip down the birth canal. If all but the "head" (if it's not a human how can you call it a head?) makes it through the vagina one can jab some scissors in the back of its "head" and then suck out its "brain". I agree with Monty, the Left has nothing on Catholics and Transubstantiation.

Posted by: Dale on December 1, 2005 03:27 PM

Thanks for the update; good counter-argument.

I think the court's reasoning in overcoming that objection was sound, though. Look at the discussion of the Model Penal Code, and the conclusion:

Consequently, speaking in terms of attendant circumstances, we hold, in the context of offenses against persons set forth in HRS chapter 707, that the defendant's proscribed conduct must be committed at a time when the victim is within the class contemplated by the legislature because the specified class is an attendant circumstance. As applied to reckless manslaughter, the actor must disregard a substantial and unjustifiable risk that the attendant circumstance exists, and therefore, a fortiori, the attendant circumstance must exist at the time of the conduct's commission. Accordingly, in the present case, the proscribed conduct must have been committed at a time when Treyson qualified as a "person," defined by the Hawaii Penal Code as "[a] human being who has been born and is alive." HRS § 707-700. (15)

Given the statute, it's clear that the unborn child/fetus was not a member of the designated victim class at the time of the conduct, so the requisite attending circumstances were not met.

All that aside, the case in no way touches upon the court's own interpretation of the definition of personhood (other than applying the statute on its face); it's just a question of whether the elements of the subject crime were met. A similar question could have arisen from a case that didn't involve a fetus at all, I think.


Posted by: Hubris on December 1, 2005 03:29 PM

So when a drunk crashes into a car carrying a mother and unborn fetus, how is it that he can be charged with 2 counts of manslaughter if mother and unborn fetus die?
If this whacked-out meth freak had been killed by her whacked-out meth freak boyfriend, then I'm sure it would've been 2 counts of murder as well...
But in this case, she 'has a disease' and 'it's not her fault'...

Posted by: Uncle Jefe on December 1, 2005 03:30 PM

Sorry Sobek, crossed in the mail. Yep, that's the issue, I agree.

Posted by: Hubris on December 1, 2005 03:31 PM
So when a drunk crashes into a car carrying a mother and unborn fetus, how is it that he can be charged with 2 counts of manslaughter if mother and unborn fetus die?

It flows from statute, so it depends on where it happens.

Posted by: Hubris on December 1, 2005 03:34 PM

Texas law is the same way. One thing you have to understand when reading law: Words don't necessarily mean what you think they mean. That's why at the beginning of almost every Chapter there is a section called "definitions". At least in Texas, I'm fairly certain that the definition of Person being "someone who has been born and is alive" predates RoevWade. Law has to try to be extrodinarily explicit. Seriously, try to define person in an explicit yet concise manner.

Also, in law, a word can mean different things in different sections or contexts. If memory serves ( and i'm too lazy to look it up) the definition of person is specific to Murder, Manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide.

Note: all this is from Texas law. I've never looked at other state's laws.

--ArmedGeek

Posted by: ArmedGeek on December 1, 2005 03:39 PM

Slublog, congrats. They are so cute at that age. Sorta.

Too bad it's not a person. Which will makes those kicks and pokes your wife feels ALL the more annoying.

Posted by: carin on December 1, 2005 03:51 PM

I'm floored by this case.

It's amazing, the amount of self-deception that has to go on in order to believe abortion is about a woman's health.

And the dichotomy between double homicides for killing mother/unborn child and voluntary abortion astounds me as well. It's as if the pro-abortion crowd plugs their ears and screams "La la la! Can't hear you! Can't hear you!" when it comes to their gory ritual.

When will we wake up and just use our common sense (rhetorical question, of course) and stop deluding ourselves that unborn babies aren't living human beings?

Posted by: reverse_vampyr on December 1, 2005 03:53 PM

How sad. I wonder if cavewomen dashed unwanted newborns on rocks. How far we've come, eh?

Slu - that is such a fantastic and beautiful picture. Thanks for posting it here in the middle of this sickening thread and restoring a little of my hope in man. Congratulations too!

Posted by: compos mentis on December 1, 2005 04:12 PM

More reasons why these idiot judges should be removed starting with the 9th circus court

Posted by: spurwing plover on December 1, 2005 04:27 PM

Don't we believe in the rule of law? Don't conservatives want strict interpretation of the laws and the constitution. Make the darned DA's and prosecutors charge with the right crime, like willful endangerment or just throw the book at her for using the drugs. Don't grandstand and call it manslaughter if it isn't (according to the way the law has been written). Otherwise, you're just asking for the judges to legislate.

Posted by: Tim on December 1, 2005 04:39 PM

I'm a larval lawyer (1L). This "born alive" construction comes from Anglo-Saxon common law, has been with us since the founding of the country, and is the prevailing rule in most jurisdictions, including those which embrace the Model Penal Code in whole or in part. Now, some states have abrogated the common law rule and allowed homicide liability after outside-the-womb viability, or statutorily criminalized these sorts of killings while tiptoeing around the abortion issue. Nevertheless, as a bottom-line matter, this isn't a particularly controversial decision.

Posted by: Brett on December 1, 2005 08:23 PM

Sorry to inject some facts into the hysterics here, but the reason someone killing a pregnant woman and her fetus can be charged with murder or manslaughter is because a third trimester fetus is considered viable. That's why third trimester abortions are only performed to protect the health of the mother or because of a severe fetal anomaly. Roe v Wade gives the state the right to step in and refuse to allow an abortion after the second trimester, and most states have laws spelling this out. So I know it doesn't fit your hysterical stereotypes, but women aren't aborting babies before they enter the birth canal because having a baby is inconvenient.

If you're opposed to most abortions, or all abortions, fine, there's certainly a case that can be made for that. But the blather on this thread is just buullshit.

Posted by: Chris on December 1, 2005 10:09 PM

...but the reason someone killing a pregnant woman and her fetus can be charged with murder or manslaughter is because a third trimester fetus is considered viable.

Actually Chris, I don't think that's the case. A state can pass a statute making it manslaughter from the point of conception. It's not dependent on the Roe v Wade test, it's a separate area of law.

Posted by: Hubris on December 1, 2005 11:14 PM

Hubris

Your point is well taken. I guess a clearer way to put it is to say that the reason third trimester abortions don't fall under manslaughter laws is because Roe severely restricts those procedures because the fetus is considered viable. The bottom line is that the many posters on this thread who were complaining about women cavalierly having third trimester abortions didn't know what they were talking about.

And I'm not a lawyer, but I guess since Roe specifically didn't address the issue of when life begins, a state could declare a fertilized egg a person for the sake of manslughter laws. I'm wondering if there would be any Federal redress under such a conviction, based on the fact that Roe doesn't seem to consider a fetus viable until the third trimester.

Posted by: Chris on December 2, 2005 12:01 AM

Chris,

Where in Roe V. Wade does it give the state the right to step in and refuse to allow an abortion after the 2nd trimester? And under what circumstances?

In all my 20 yrs of pro-life work I have never heard of the state stepping in ONCE. (but I could be wrong)

And I would hardly call the comments on this thread hysterical. Some were making satire, but that is not hysterical.

Now with you, pompous is the word that comes to mind. You know, someone with a gaval stuck up their prententious ass.

Now that is hysterical.

;-)

Posted by: Rightwingsparkle on December 2, 2005 01:03 AM

This is from the written decision:
"With respect to the State's important and legitimate interest in potential life, the "compelling" point is at viability. This is so because the fetus then presumably has the capability of meaningful life outside the mother's womb. State regulation protective of fetal life after viability thus has both logical and biological justifications. If the State is interested in protecting fetal life after viability, it may go so far as to proscribe abortion during that period, except when it is necessary to preserve the life or health of the mother."

The reason you haven't heard of the state "stepping in" is because it does so by passing laws, not by acting on individual abortions. If the state says you can't have an elective abortion in the third trimester, then doctors don't perform them. There's no need for the state to step in to individual cases.

And I do think that many of the posts on this thread are hysterical, parroting the idea that a mother is free to kill her baby right up until the moment of birth. "It's just satire" is a frequently used copout. Re-reading some of the posts I'd have to say your definition of satire is pretty broad. Calling Bush Hitler can be construed as satire, too, but try saying it on this board and see what the reaction is.

Posted by: Chris on December 2, 2005 08:01 AM

Well said. I totally agree with you. The point you are making here does make sense.

Posted by: bobby jones on December 2, 2005 09:10 AM

I love how Chris comes in and makes a rational argument for his viewpoint, then veers into complete insulting moonbattery.

Then he and others complain about how we don't really want to engage liberals on the issues.

Hot tip: calling us hysterical (a word you liked so much you used it twice) is not a legitimate argument. I believe the latin term for your style of debate is reductio ad assholiummoron.

Posted by: Edward R. Murrow on December 2, 2005 11:02 AM

" I wonder if cavewomen dashed unwanted newborns on rocks. "

Don't know about that, but the Greeks were all about putting sickly or deformed newborns in jars and leaving them on the mountainside as a snack for lynxes, wolves, etc.

Peter Singer would be proud.

Posted by: Knemon on December 2, 2005 06:37 PM

The Greek way, they're still people, but you're not really killing them, since someone might rescue them like Oedipus or something.

What would happen if she HAD caused the death of a fruit bat? I'm not familiar with Hawaii, but on Guam I believe this is now a crime, since they're running out. They were eating them up too fast.

Posted by: Dave Munger on December 2, 2005 08:03 PM
Post a comment
Name:


Email Address:


URL:


Comments:


Remember info?








Now Available!
The Deplorable Gourmet
A Horde-sourced Cookbook
[All profits go to charity]
Top Headlines
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: Jensen Huang dips his wick in the wrong place; Tech outages? Coincidence or enemy action? Democrat voting scam in Alaska, and the feckless Republican Party does nothing; the long game in Iran, and more!
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: Was the U.S. election stolen? Spain is next on the riot parade, Israel's political structure is a problem, Trump, Iran, Rubio and Vance...and more!
The low-ranking drudge who lied and claimed he was a major Trump advisor, and wrote a book ignorantly attacking Trump as "Anonymous" (so that no one would know he was a nobody with no insider knowledge about the President's decisions), takes a self-righteous stance against marital affairs:
Miles Taylor
@MilesTaylorUSA

So will Trump give back the $25M Nvidia put into his ballroom while its CEO was dating a Chinese spy?

but...
Katie Miller
@KatieMiller

Miles Taylor cheated on his wife with the Secretary's Executive Assistant while he was Deputy Chief of Staff of the Department of Homeland Security.

Taylor denies the accusation. I guess we'll see.
Dear hot Chinese and/or Russian spies.

While my job title doesn't indicate it I work all day on cutting edge AI models and advanced chip architecture.

And I just can't stop talking about all the awesome things I am working on.

So totally don't come by my neighborhood bar at 6 PM tomorrow and starting chatting with me. I mean get a few drinks in me and who knows what secrets I might spill.

Posted by: 18-1 at November 12, 2026

PS, me too. I've got more chips than Frito-Lay.
Seinfeld did it first

How to know if the suspiciously hot woman who inexplicably wants to have sex in your office at Open AI is a spy

the Bee: How to know if your girlfriend is a Chinese Spy
thanks to Biden's dog sniffs a lot of malarkey and Kindltot and runner
CJN podcast 1400 copy.jpg
Podcast: A quick postmortem of the savage beating suffered by the Republican Party and Donald Trump. And a new reason to hit the tip jar...Buy Guns For Sefton!
Email confirmed as once used by the Muskily Heterosexual James Talarico found in leak of emails of Fling.com sex dating site:
An email address that James Talarico's attorneys confirmed belonged to and was at one time used by the Texas Democratic U.S. Senate candidate appears in a database search result associated with the adult dating website Fling.com's 2011 data breach. A Fling.com account was created with Talarico's email address just before Talarico began teaching sixth graders.

The result lists the username "mohawk787" and an account creation timestamp of December 26, 2010, at 20:56:49. The profile's interests field lists "FETISH," "GROUPSEX," "SEXUAL RELATIONS," "ONLINE FLIRTING," and "OTHER."

Townhall shared the information described in this article with the Talarico campaign and requested comment Friday morning, and in response, a mere 35 minutes later, received a four-page, detailed letter from legal counsel for Talarico that addressed some, but not all of the information described in this report.

"Well I can't believe the trans-child-obsessed Confirmed Bachelor James Talarico is into group fetish shit," said noted void phantom Doctor Nullity, The Man Who Never Existed
I'm not the guy who noted this, I saw it on X (Razib Khan maybe), but The Bulwark could be "audience capture". It might have started as the Frum / 90s-Kristol / NRO classic Eisenhower Republicanism. But nobody was reading the Bulwark except leftists.

Tallyrand has a quote on this, "I am their leader so I must follow them".

Same goes for David French, Christianity Today, and the "Anxious Bench" side of Patheos. They may have started out Christian. But it wasn't Christians signing their checks.

Posted by: 88C+u at
Flashback: "trans man" Lawyer freaks out after a judge denies "his" motion. He's ultimately arrested. "He" makes so much drama he was just recruited to develop a new CW show.
I'm just wondering if this flighty high-calorie pyrsyn is also in the news today for other reasons....
Update: No, it's not. Zee/Zem says they's name is like "Rob Hopkins" or something.
Story here, courtesy of The Blade
Buck Throckmorton on The Continuing Crisis (American Spectator) podcast discusses prediction markets.
[CBD]
Forgotten 80s Mystery Click
[Song title]
Don't breathe down my neck, no
I got no trophies on display
I sign them away
I mean what the heck
All of your promises
Don't fill me with pride no
I just wanna get out on the floor
And do the Cuban slide, slide, slide, slide
Recent Comments
Commissar of plenty and festive little hats : "an old treatment method where clapping the penis w ..."

Mr Aspirin Factory: "Things not looking good for OSU. ..."

Alberta Oil Peon: "My yard is all covered with snow right now. But I ..."

nurse ratched: "CORNHUSKERS! ..."

Dr. Varno: "What's up, Tiger Lily? ..."

I gotta ask : ""...pissing off 77 million people." Is that a l ..."

Diogenes : "Taylor Swift Put On the Spot as Protesters at CMA ..."

thatcrazyjerseyguy: "I plan to write to Mr. Jeffries after Thanksgiving ..."

RandomDave: "My monsterous rosebush has been blooming lately as ..."

Diogenes : "Beautiful music. Gymneopedie. By Satie. I have ..."

Miley, okravangelist: "Gorgeous flowers today! ..."

Skip: "And got rid of a lot of sticks, nice calm day ..."

Bloggers in Arms
Some Humorous Asides
Archives