« Breaking: Fighting Terrorists... Works | Main | Shock: Oliver Willis Actually Makes a Good Point »
June 21, 2004

The Birth of a Meme: "Punitive Liberalism"


James Taranto teases the notion:

Writing in The Weekly Standard, James Piereson offers a useful addition to the American political glossary: "punitive liberalism." This "bizarre doctrine," which found its fullest expression in the presidency of Jimmy Carter, holds that "America had been responsible for numerous crimes and misdeeds through its history for which it deserved punishment and chastisement." Those who disagree "were written off as ignorant patriots who could not face up to the sins of the past."

This makes so much sense I am physically angered that I didn't think of it first. I am beating the stuffings out of my therapist-prescribed "Anger Puppets." My Anger Puppets are supposed to teach me the difference between "good touching" and "criminal assault." But I've stripped the clothes off them and I'm now arranging them in a naked puppet pyramid.

I may force one puppet to have sex with a Kenner(TM) Jabba's Prisoner Princess Leia figure. That'll show him.

Why do liberals always support military action when there is no national security threat implicated (Kosovo, Haiti, etc.) but start preaching pacificism when there is (Afghanistan, Iraq, Iran, North Korea)?

Because we have sinned. We have to send troops to Haiti as pennance for our sins. We have to bomb Serbia for 77 days because we stole this country from the Indians.

But when a country actually threatens us?

Heavens! We daren't take military action. That would inure to our national-security self-interests, and we're not deserving of acting in our own best interests.

Perhaps, one day, after we've transferred one half of the country's wealth to Africa and the Middle East, then the ledger will be evened-up and we will be able to occasionally act in our own interests, as non-sinful countries like France are allowed to do.

But until that day-- we can act only in order to vindicate someone else's interests. Never, never, never our own.

posted by Ace at 04:50 PM

It's an interesting theory, but explain to me how, exactly, our actions in Somalia (for example) were in anyone's interests? The military disasters you listed weren't just examples of American altruism, they were examples of us sending troops to places without considering anyone's interests whatsoever.

Posted by: Aaron on June 21, 2004 05:17 PM

"My Anger Puppets are supposed to teach me the difference between "good touching" and "criminal assault." But I've stripped the clothes off them and I'm now arranging them in a naked puppet pyramid. "

Just.F*ing.Brilliant! Haven't laughed this hard since Allah went all gloomy. Poor dear!

Speaking of the beloved deity, someone needs to go and get him drunk, and possibly laid. I'd volunteer, but I have some,er, moral constraints about consorting with a deity.

Meanwhile, I have no constraints about reading your blog....and liking it.

Posted by: Joan of Argghh! on June 21, 2004 05:27 PM

Hey Joan...I'm feeling down, and I'm not a Diety (or an angel for that matter)...nudge, nudge.

Be careful with those puppets Ace! Sully might get wind of their "torture" and spend 3 weeks agonizing over whether he should read your blog or Oliver Willis'.

Posted by: on June 21, 2004 05:51 PM

Grrrr... I had the last post (hitting on poor Joan)..but forgot my info, as is typical these days.

Posted by: Senator PhilABuster on June 21, 2004 05:52 PM

"President" Clinton echoed this theme at a talk at Georgetown University, saying in essence that we deserved 9/11 due to our past sins. The WaPo was there and declined to report on this outrage.

Posted by: dib on June 21, 2004 05:52 PM

I'm willing to bet Jimmy Carter and those who share his beliefs were laughable dodge ball players. They were the tubby kids who got consistently clipped on the skull or on the back of the knees as they fled in terror from that screaming, redrubber alpha male decider.

This is just a theory I'm working on, mind you, but anecdotally at least, it's ironclad.

Posted by: Jeff G on June 21, 2004 05:57 PM

I heard someone compare Republicans to a good parent who encourages the kids to keep trying. Then they compared liberals to an abusive parent who tells the kids they'll never amount to anything and that they'll always need help.

Posted by: rdbrewer on June 21, 2004 06:11 PM

Hey Ace, I think you missed the real story on WSJ's OpinionJournal:

Parkhudin, a 26-year-old Afghan farmer who was held at Guantánamo from February 2003 to March 2004, said in an interview in Khost that he had been questioned for up to 20 hours at a time under uncomfortable conditions at Guantánamo. He said he had been shackled with a small chain during questioning. ''They made me stand in front of an air-conditioner,'' he said. ''The wind was very cold.''

First, we rape them, then we turn on the fans? Will the horror never cease?

Posted by: Shawn on June 21, 2004 08:49 PM

Yep, very well written piece, although I'm with Taranto - it ain't dead yet.

But Reagan made it look boneheaded to hate America for 8 years.

Posted by: Dave in Texas on June 21, 2004 09:03 PM

Wait, let me get this straight. A native of Afghanistan (mountainous country with balls-shatteringly cold weather) imprisoned in Guantanamo Bay, Cuba (Island country with balls-scorchingly hot weather) is complaining about AC?


Posted by: Brian B on June 21, 2004 09:03 PM

I'm willing to bet Jimmy Carter and those who share his beliefs were laughable dodge ball players. They were the tubby kids who got consistently clipped on the skull...

So that's how Carter got that way.

It's an interesting theory but it doesn't hold up: I was a nerdy wuss in school too and look at me: all conservative and everything! I must've been one of the lucky ones...

Posted by: Smack on June 21, 2004 11:34 PM

I was also a nerdy wuss who got beat at Dodgeball all the time.
It taught me that pain means nothing if there is no actual injury, and to keep trying against impossible odds and that "losing less badly than before" is still a victory of sorts, and better than giving up or whining about it.

Posted by: nathan on June 22, 2004 01:28 AM

So, sorry, they theory doesn't hold. I sucked at dodgeball too. Got clipped all the time. All it taught me was that when the other kid has a red rubber ball, get yourself a JDAM.

Through that red rubber ball, sucker, I dare you.

Posted by: Brock on June 22, 2004 10:14 AM

So when does the War on Liberals/Leftists begin?

Posted by: recon on June 22, 2004 12:49 PM
Post a comment

Email Address:



Remember info?

The AoSHQ Amazon Store

Now Available!
The Deplorable Gourmet
A Horde-sourced Cookbook
[All profits go to charity]
Top Headlines
CJN podcast sidebar.jpg
CJN Speaks: Episode 2. Sefton & CBD rant about Rittenhouse, give a couple of mea culpas, and more!
I was a guest of the great Rob Schilling on his "Schilling Show Unleashed" podcast where we discussed my new book and "the dissolution of the United States, right before our eyes. From election tampering to January 6 and beyond Sefton details the indicators of a lost culture and a lost nation." Click here and have a listen. [J.J.]
It's Matt Taibbi's brand, put together by video contributor Matt Orfalea.
Both are lefties.
I'm sorry, what are we paying the Conservative Grifter Class for, again? What is the point of them? What would you say they do here?

Now any 17 year old will feel free to cross state lines. Heckuva job, America.

Note she's a lefty but apparently mocking the "HE CROSSED STATE LINES!" obsession of the shitlib media. She's even making fun of righties who are making fun of her for saying this. But, you know, can you blame us? We're literally hearing this seriously offered as Real Crime by every shitlib in the media and by ever shitlib on Twitter. And this is quite a subtle parody.
But this particular leftwinger sees the absurdity of it all and is mocking the shitlibs. Honestly a lot of the farther-left leftwingers are not buying into this at all. Unlike, say, the National Review "conservative" neoliberal types. "He shouldn't have been there," you know.
It is very eye-opening to see the " " " conservatives " " " trying to hang this kid and far-leftwingers grasping, against normal tribal interest, that he's completely innocent, and no, "crossing state lines" doesn't change that, and no, "he shouldn't have been there" doesn't make him a villain.
Notice how the Conservative Grifter Class simply repeats every single talking point they hear from their Very Good Friends on CNN and MSNBC and in the NYT and Washington Post. It's almost a if they're... politically and personally allied or something.
Harmeet K. Dhillon

Is anyone planning to CROSS STATE LINES for Thanksgiving? Be sure to check with your on-call lawyer or choice for legal advice!
The Brain Trust at ESPN has some piercing legal thoughts about the Rittenhouse Trial, starting with "he crossed state lines"
I'm going to make a Spaghetti Western style retelling of the Rittenhouse Justice Ride. It will be called,
I'm seeing freeze-frame introductions of the villains, "IL PEDO"/"Short-Eyes," "IL BIMBO SULLO SKATE"/"Skater-Boi," and "MANCINO"/"Lefty."
And of course a freeze-frame introduction of our hero, "L'UOMO DALLE MANI VIOLA"/"The Man With Purple Hands."
Hoo-hah, hoohah, hoo-hah, hoohah whipcrack...
Maybe I'll throw in Skater-Boi's unsatisfied, abused girlfriend as a love interest, "SIGNORINA ASSETATA"/"Miss Thirsty."
Guys, Gittenhouse (Gittings + Rittenhouse) is going to happen
Taketh thou thy bounty of battle-earnt quim, O Conqueror King
This whole compilation of highlights from week three of the trial is good, but the bonus at the end -- a supercut of Fatlock making stupid Chris Farley Show level observations, and then obsessively checking things off his stupid fat checklist with his stupid husky-sized pen -- is hilarious and a must watch
I want to Fat Shame this guy into bulimia
The clips from Fatlock here are almost all from his reBUTTal. It was embarrassing to watch. He made almost no eye contact with the jury-- he just maintained eye-lock with his stupid checklist. You could smell the flop-sweat wafting above the stink of the regular sweat. He was like a fat third-grader speed-reading through his book report in front of the class because he'd pooped his pants and wanted to finish before the smell hit the front row.
P3dophiles Lives Matter!
@Cernovich 9m

Those saying CNN shouldn't be worried about lawsuits need only watch their recent report to see ... their general counsel is VERY concerned


Posted by: Tami

Meanwhile, MSNBC/NBC says YOLO, in for a dime, in for a hundred million dollars!
Recent Comments
Tonypete: "Or, if you're a cheese-ass, use the blade of your ..."

MkY: "Heard he has gotten married, and changed his entir ..."

Quint: " I wonder why these aren't still airing? Any ideas ..."

davidt: "Miracle Whip for leftover turkey sammich, not mayo ..."

NaCly Dog (u82oZ): "One of my profs told me about the famous Chem prof ..."

Doof: "Weasel's sammich is classic and very good. Repl ..."

Anna Puma: "People at anytime can get focused on 'getting ther ..."

Taqiyyologist, Rickrolled by Jesus: "Posted by: Skip at November 26, 2021 08:23 PM T ..."

clutch cargo - processed in a facility that may contain lead: "[i]Leftover cranberry sauce (store-bought, and sau ..."

rhomboid: "AZ deplorable, that's on my list when doing my mus ..."

Eromero: "Old-timey Eromeros went to church 3 times a week. ..."

MIMimi aka Mimi or MI if'n you're into the brevity thing: "I went thru several nukes drills when I briefly at ..."

Bloggers in Arms
Some Humorous Asides